Holybro x500 V2 Motors harsh sound and getting hot when arming

I am currently using holybro x500 V2 with orange cube.

when I arm the copter, the motors sound is so harsh and even get hot, but when I calibrate the ESCs and in the last step when I raise the throttle , the motor sound is smooth, but again when i reboot the copter and arm it , the motor sound is very harsh again with lots of vibration. I tried every thing i know and didn’t got lucky to solve the problem

At the end I used PX4 instead of Arducopter and the problem gone and motor sound is smooth when arming.
I reinstalled arducopter instead of px4 and the problem is happening again
I guess is parameter problem but dont know where exactly

looking forward for your guidance
Thank you

Did you tune and activated the notch filter?
Did you perform the mandatory hardware setup?
What are your vibration levels?

Provide a .bin log, it sounds like D term is too high but there could be more, like vibration issues.

Dear @xfacta
thank you for your response
kindly find the .bin fine in this link
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Tb3aU1a8DLEK4HR3W6s4Ynn69CashDAf/view?usp=sharing

Dear @amilcarlucas
I did the mandatory hardware setup but not the notch filter, the vibration level is so high, actually it goes and back, for example when I arm the copter for longer time, motors stay with harsh sound for long time then become smooth for 1 or 2 seconds, then become harsh again, and become also hot

I cant see an obvious reason in the parameters for all the oscillations, but it is very bad

I would start by reducing these to half their present values
image

Then checking and rechecking prop rotation and order using MissionPlanner motor test.
Also check prop and motor balance → use the motor test to spin each one and see if any produce unacceptable vibrations or are out of balance.
Ensure all the motors and props are properly aligned and not twisted on the arms.

What is the flight controller anti-vibration mount like? Too soft maybe? A Cube may not need any anti-vibration mount. Please supply a photo.

Don’t try to fly this until you are sure it’s fixed.

thank you for your answer
I have modified the parameters, I cut them half, still same results.
regarding the prop, all my tests have been done without prop, all those vibrations are from the motors alone without prop.
when I test the motor from mission planner ( Optional hardware - motor test ) motor sound is very smooth.
the problem appear when I arm the motor and raise the throttle , then becomes very harsh sound.
I don’t think the problem is from the anti vibration, am using orange cube anyway, since the motor test shows smooth sound for the motors.


In fact Orange CUBE was specifically made for PX4 firmware functions in some ways as far as I see. I too had the my QUADCOPTER going smooth on first instance using PX4 firmware on Orange CUBE . I am not a fan of either firmwares but i can see the results on first instance

This is not true, Cubepilot recommends and gives support for users running Ardupilot. The difference you noted between different softwares can be caused by tons of factors.

1 Like

That’s for sure.
Cube

1 Like

Just a quick look in parameters and I see your battery is set to 6S ?!?
When you set initial parameters, it ask for battery type and propellers length , this is important to set it correctly as the controller is expecting to work with these parameters.

Here are the parameters of my X500 v2
x500-gps-cal2 (1).param (17.5 KB)

Thank you guys for all your answers.
Problem has been solved.
the problem that I was putting the cube in this kind of double face to stick it to the copter and i was not hard mounting it to the frame.
after that , the harsh sound gone and motor is smooth again.