Autotune gives poor tuning values on roll axis and causing vibration on arms

@xfacta I am expecting a suggestion from you, will you please have a look.

The fact that you have not addressed vibration by any other means than damping the mount suggests that you have not addressed the root cause. As such, I think you are getting somewhat predictable disastrous results. As Shawn and Brandon have stated, over-damping is not the solution here.

In fairness, I did not review the logs, just the overall context of the posts.

There is a lot history in this thread Iā€™m not going to review but in that last log your Roll input, and Pitch for that matter, set up an increasing oscillation indicative of the Rate P&I values being too low. I would put Rate Roll/Pitch kP on an in-flight tuning pot with the low end at default and the high end double that and do some testing. But, thatā€™s just how I do things; you need a good handle on manual tuning to proceed down that path. And, itā€™s time consuming. But if you have been at this for 2 months I suppose you have the timeā€¦

Thank you, but I did manual tuning before proceeding to autotune but in alt hold it was stable when I fly in loiter it started oscillating. Later I did quicktune in loiter mode and followed autotune. As a see I didnā€™t get proper tune even though being run autotune 2 times on each axis .I got PIDs too low later by manual I increased PIDs and made the drone stable. I the second log which I have posted, I have done maneuver for all the axes it was doing good. Later I landed and after Reboot again I tookoff to see performance, in loiter mode slightly I gave roll input at 3m altitude. It started oscillating and toppled and crash. I didnā€™t get when then drone did stable flight test in 2 nd log with the same parameters after reboot it crashed.

I cant see whatā€™s causing the oscillations in that latest log, But I can see yaw is drifting ahead of the desired yaw heading without any yaw stick input. To me this says there is a physical yaw problem, but I dont see in the motor outputs like we do with a twisted motor mount. Maybe props are in the wrong order or something odd like that.

Get a video of the MissionPlanner motor test when you press ā€œAll in sequenceā€ and lets see that.

This is the order (A, B, C, D) and the rotations:
image

Yes I have observed yaw drifting after takeoff as I thought it might be because of internal imu causing the issue or the yaw angle is 6.8 . If I keep yaw angle to default value drifting was not observed. If you see the second log there is also a yaw drifting but while takeoff from ground there is a slight oscillations after which it was stable.

Motor order and directions are correct before takeoff we did motor test on the ground . I didnā€™t understand after takeoff when I gave slight roll input.it suddenly oscillated and crashed.

In my opinion, this carbon fiber eggshell looks nice but may not be rigid enough.